A $852,000 Verdict After the Insurer Said "No Damage, No Injury"

No visible damage, a clean MRI, and an insurer that denied any injury — yet a Stockton jury returned an $852,000 verdict. See how Schwinghamer Law won.

Written by Noah Schwinghamer | 27 Jun 2026

Share this article

Close-up of the rear tail light and bumper of a white car

Quick Summary

Our client's small car was rear-ended by a commercial van. Because there was no visible damage to the car, the insurance company insisted no injury was possible — even though our client needed surgery. The injury also did not appear on a standard MRI, so the defense hired multiple experts to deny it existed and to call the surgery unnecessary. Schwinghamer Law took the case to trial. By uncovering vehicle damage the insurer's investigation had missed, confirming the disc injury with a discogram, and presenting accident-reconstruction and biomechanical experts, we proved the crash caused the surgery. A Stockton jury returned a verdict of $852,000.

What happened?

Our client was driving a small car when it was rear-ended by a commercial van. Because there was no obvious damage to our client's vehicle, the insurance company took the position that the crash could not have caused any injury. In reality, our client was significantly injured — and ultimately needed surgery.

Why did the insurance company deny the claim?

The insurer leaned on a familiar tactic: no visible vehicle damage, therefore no possible injury. The challenge grew because our client's injury did not show up on a standard MRI. Seizing on that, the defense hired multiple experts to argue that no injury existed at all — and that the surgery our client underwent was unreasonable and unnecessary.

Why did this case go to trial?

The two sides were worlds apart. Our client had an injury serious enough to require surgery, while the insurance company refused to admit the forces of the crash could have caused any injury at all. With a gap that wide, there was no fair settlement to be reached — so Mr. Schwinghamer took the case to trial.

How did we prove the crash was forceful enough to cause injury?

First, Mr. Schwinghamer went straight to the source. He personally met with the technician who repaired our client's vehicle and learned that the car had additional damage the insurance company's own investigation had missed. That overlooked damage undercut the central premise of the defense — that this was a harmless, no-damage collision. At trial, our team reinforced that evidence with an accident reconstruction expert, who demonstrated the forces involved in the crash, and a biomechanical expert, who explained why those forces were more than enough to cause our client's injury.

How did we prove the injury when the MRI looked normal?

Not every injury is visible on a standard MRI. To document our client's disc injury, the treating physicians performed a discogram (also called discography). In that procedure, contrast dye is injected into the intervertebral disc suspected of being damaged. If the disc is torn, the dye can be seen leaking through the tear on imaging — in real time. The discogram confirmed the disc injury, and that injury was confirmed again when it was treated surgically.

What was the outcome?

The jury saw through the “no damage, no injury” defense. After hearing the evidence, a Stockton jury found that our client's surgery was caused by the crash and returned a verdict of $852,000.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Can you be seriously injured in a "low-damage" or low-speed car accident?
A: Yes. The amount of visible damage to a vehicle is not a reliable measure of whether the people inside were hurt. Vehicles and human bodies absorb crash forces differently, and serious injuries can occur even when a car looks largely undamaged. Insurance companies often argue otherwise, but juries can and do reject that argument.

Q: Can you have a real injury that does not show up on an MRI?
A: Yes. A standard MRI does not capture every injury. Some disc and soft-tissue injuries are difficult to see on routine imaging, and additional diagnostic tools — such as a discogram — are sometimes needed to pinpoint the source of a patient's pain.

Q: What is a discogram?
A: A discogram, or discography, is a diagnostic procedure in which a physician injects contrast dye into an intervertebral disc suspected of being injured. If the disc has a tear, the dye can be seen leaking through it on imaging, which helps confirm the injury when other scans are inconclusive.

Q: Should I trust an insurance company that says my accident was too minor to cause injury?
A: Be cautious. “No visible damage, no injury” is a common way to minimize or deny valid claims. If you were hurt, it is worth getting prompt medical care and speaking with an attorney before accepting any offer, because the value of your claim may be far greater than the insurer suggests.

DISCLAIMER

The results described above reflect the specific facts of one client's case. Past results do not guarantee or predict the outcome of any other matter; every case is different. This page is attorney advertising and is provided for general information only — it is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship.

DISCLAIMER

Share this article

About the Author

Noah Schwinghamer

Noah Schwinghamer is the founding attorney of Schwinghamer Law in Stockton, California. With over a decade of experience in personal injury law, Noah is dedicated to helping individuals and families stand up to powerful insurance companies and recover the compensation they deserve. He has successfully taken on major insurers, Fortune 500 companies, and government entities — and has recovered millions of dollars for his clients. His mission is simple: leave every client better than he found them.

Injured in a Car Accident? We're Here to Help.

After a car accident, insurance companies often work to pay as little as possible: disputing your injuries, your treatment, or who was at fault. If you or a loved one was hurt in a crash, Schwinghamer Law can handle the insurers, build your case, and fight for the full value of your claim, with the clarity, compassion, and courtroom experience these cases demand. Your consultation is always free.

Call Now (209) 425-2520

Or Send Us a Message

Schwinghamer Law – The Stockton Hammer, personal injury attorney in Stockton, California

Stockton Office

7400 Shoreline Dr. #5

Stockton, CA 95219

(209) 425-2520